Shifting gears higher - digital slides in graduate education - 4 years experience at Semmelweis University
© Fónyad et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2010
Received: 17 August 2010
Accepted: 22 November 2010
Published: 22 November 2010
The spreading of whole slide imaging or digital slide systems in pathology as an innovative technique seems to be unstoppable. Successful introduction of digital slides in education has played a crucial role to reach this level of acceptance. Practically speaking there is no university institute where digital materials are not built into pathology education. At the 1st. Department of Pathology and Experimental Cancer Research, Semmelweis University optical microscopes have been replaced and for four years only digital slides have been used in education. The aim of this paper is to summarize our experiences gathered with the installation of a fully digitized histology lab for graduate education.
We have installed a digital histology lab with 40 PCs, two slide servers - one for internal use and one with external internet access. We have digitized hundreds of slides and after 4 years we use a set of 126 slides during the pathology course. A Student satisfaction questionnaire and a Tutor satisfaction questionnaire have been designed, both to be completed voluntarily to have feed back from the users. The page load statistics of the external slide server were evaluated.
The digital histology lab served ~900 students and ~1600 hours of histology practice. The questionnaires revealed high satisfaction with digital slides. The results also emphasize the importance of the tutors' attitude towards digital microscopy as a factor influencing the students' satisfaction. The constantly growing number of page downloads from the external server confirms this satisfaction and the acceptance of digital slides.
We are confident, and have showed as well, that digital slides have got numerous advantages over optical slides and are more suitable in education.
Pathology is a discipline dealing with the development of diseases, their aetiology and effects on the human body, being closely correlated to prevention, diagnosis and therapy. It is one of the most important medical disciplines, connecting morphological changes to clinical aspects, therefore the study and knowledge of pathology is essential for the understanding of clinical subjects. Pathology courses - and teaching in general - is facing many challenges today, and has to deal with several intriguing questions, like:
1. How could the different pathology curriculums (graduate and postgraduate) set by the governments, integrate the constantly growing knowledge of sciences with precise standards while preserving the lucidity and manageability of the topics the students have to master?
2. How could universities apply different teaching and learning methods (For example: problem based learning, inquiry-based learning, augmented learning, cooperative learning, distance learning, e-learnig etc.)?
3. How could the advances of computer sciences be maximized in pathological education?
Answering the first two questions is far beyond the prospect of this paper. For the third question the spreading of digital microscopes in all fields of pathology [1–8] especially in the histopathology classrooms Worldwide may provide a suitable answer [9–12].
Pathology curriculum framework for graduate education in the medical course of the 1st. Department of Pathology and Experimental Cancer Research, Semmelweis University
We have designed a pathology curriculum that fundamentally has a clinico-pathological point of view. During our lectures, seminars and practices we aim to provide an approach that will enable our students to develop a medical way of thinking, to formulate evidence based judgements, and enhance their diagnostic skills. Pathology at Semmelweis University is a 2 semester subject covering 224 teaching hours for lectures and practices.
Two 90 minute long lectures are held each week. The topics discussed in the first semester cover basic pathological changes, and the second semester covers the diseases of the different organ systems (detailed organ specific pathology).
There are similarly two 90 minute long practices weekly. The practical training consists of 30 autopsy practices, 18 histology seminars and 8 specimen consultations. The goal of the autopsy practices is to describe the basic pathomorphological changes based on the previous anatomic knowledge, and to correlate the morphological findings with the clinical picture. After the autopsy is performed each case is discussed in situ with the clinicians. Students are taking an active part in such consultations. The aim of histological practices is to describe and recognize the fundamental histopathological alterations. For specimen consultation we have formalin fixed and re-colourised autopsy specimens using Romhanyi's technique, demonstrating the rare and interesting pathological entities that students do not necessarily meet with during routine autopsies.
Type of examination
Both semesters are concluded with practical (autopsy, histology and specimen recognition) and oral (two topics and explanation of one autopsy report) examination. Written tests are not used for examination.
Digital solutions in the practices
In the autopsy room we use interactive smart tables, that are connected to the laboratory information system of the University. All the clinical data of the patients (e.g. X-ray, CT, MRI images along with videos of angiography and different scope techniques) can be displayed. For histology practices we use digital slides.
The aim of the paper is to summarize our experiences gathered with the installation of a fully digitized histology lab for graduate education.
Key hardwares and softwares used
Typical scenario of a histology class using digital slides
External access for the slides
For security reasons the internal server supplying the practices can not yet be reached from outside the institute. To provide the students with continuous external access service to the educational material the slides were uploaded to http://www.pathonet.com an open access web portal providing free storage capacity for digital slides. The portal runs on 2 separate server computers, one for storing the web-pages and all text data and one for storing and handling the digital slides. The first is an Intel Xeon 2 GHz, 1 GB RAM server running on Linux, the second one is a dual Intel XEON 5150, 2 GB RAM, 4 TB HDD, running on Win2003. The slides can be opened with a free version of Mirax Viewer or with a simple Java Viewer. In the first year a handout for the slides were uploaded to the server too. Later these materials were deleted because of the educational policy of the Institute.
Histology examinations using digital slides
For the midterm and final examinations we use digital slides. A dedicated software - E-School Exam - was installed on the server. The software allows editing and compiling question sets for test papers containing close ended (simple choice question, multiple choice question) and open ended questions as well. Both the questions and the answers appear in a random order for every user after authentication, login to the server and starting an examination. Digital slides can also be linked to questions. The answer for such a question could be an image captured and uploaded by the student. From the numerous possibilities the software offers, we use only its slide linking and randomising capability.
Feed backing approaches
In the past 3 years we had 928 students registered for pathology courses including students of the Hungarian and English medical and Hungarian and English dental program. During this period the digital histology classroom served approximately 1600 hours.
Student/tutor satisfaction questionnaire
Page load statistics of the Pathonet portal
In the queries there were some questions related to the usage of the Pathonet portal. According to the students' answers in 2007/2008 97% of the students used the site and found it very useful to prepare for the examinations (8.86/10). The query this year ended similar results, respectively 98% and 9.22/10.
The success of digital microscope applications have brought a new era to medicine, especially to anatomic pathology, both in the field of research, education and routine practice. Considering the fact that the most obvious advantages of such systems appear in education it is not surprising that spreading of digital microscopes have started in the histopathology classrooms . Our results additionally show that digital slides could easily be integrated to histopathology education. The results emphasize the importance of the "human factor" in the efficiency of the installation of any new techniques confirmed by how the tutors' attitude towards digital slides affected the students' attitude. (Figure 5) Without overestimating ones age on the impact on the capability to accept and apply new innovations we have to mention that the younger the tutor was the better results were detected and vice versa. Even though the image compression resulted in a slight corruption of image quality (and an increase in the speed of slide handling) we think it is a reasonable compromise as this decline only appears in such high magnifications which a regular optical microscope in a classroom not even reaches equipped with a 20× or maximum 40× objective. The constantly increasing number of page loads from our slide server also confirms our faith in putting extra efforts to manage the portal.
In order to understand this success in pathology education we have to inspect the advantages of digital microscopes and slides over optical microscopes and slides and the possible disadvantages. Some may argue that necessity of additional investments in education (to equip a room with computers, build up a network, buy a slide scanner) is a disadvantage. Furthermore as long as digital microscopes does not replace optical ones in routine practice it could happen that a pathology resident would use a light microscope for the first time, the first day of their pathology residencies . We are convinced that the advantages of digital slides in education far outweigh the mentioned possible drawbacks. What are these advantages? Some of them could be defined as features that glass slides and optical microscopes bear as well, but with digital slides the quality of those features is increased. The next group of attributes is unique to digital slides, providing a powerful tool to teachers that is impossible to be managed using optical microscopy.
Features of digital slides providing higher quality in education or allowing simplification of the processes:
Simplified slide handling
Let us imagine a histopathology lab with 40 students sitting beside 40 microscopes using 40 slide boxes. During a pathology course a student has to learn about at least a 100 different diseases because they have a characteristic appearance under microscope and have their clinico-pathological importance, or relevance of the alteration to understand basic pathological mechanisms. 40 students sitting beside 40 microscopes using 40 slide boxes each with 100 slides gives 4000 slides to be taken care of whenever the stain faints, a slide brakes or just mysteriously disappears.
Reproducing 100 slides showing just the same alteration is literally impossible. Serial sectioning represents many different levels of the paraffin embedded samples, and the collection of 100 samples (and additional serial) of rare diseases are very problematic too. Using digital slides only one perfect sample is required. After scanning the digital slide never breaks, the stain does not faint and it shows exactly the same picture to every user.
Demostration of auxiliary techniques
It is highly expensive to prepare immunostained slides for every student or to show fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH)-slides or other fluorescent material (this requires to equip your lab with 40 fluorescent microscopes), not to mention the continuous collecting of fluorescent samples that are fainting fast. It is not impossible as long one have all the credit, but it would not be worth at all. Scanning IHC-slides or FISH with a fluorescent camera is basically the same process as the simple scanning of H&E slides and provides the above mentioned benefits.
Unique attributes of digital slides
Easier orientation on slides
Every viewer software has a thumbnail view of the slide in the main user interface. For a student who has just passed the anatomy examinations, it is a great help to orient the sample. For example in the case of a gastrointestinal tumour to judge the existence of peritoneal spreading first one has to know which is the mucosal and which is the serosal surface of the gut what could be very difficult for a student especially when the tumour destructs the normal structures.
Parallel visualization of slides
With a viewer software it is possible to open multiple slides in parallel. It could be the same slide opened twice and positioned to different areas at different magnifications. For example to show Antony-A and Antony-B areas of a schwannoma. Or open a H&E slide and the IHC slide from the same block to show the immunprofile of a tumour.
Placing annotations on digital slides
This feature helps to be tutors rather than teachers, and to apply different teaching-learning methods (e.g.: problem based learning, inquiry-based learning, distance learning, e-learnig etc) with all the supporting information about the sample and the representative areas as annotations or with direct links to scientific databases.
On special slide servers digital slides could be stored and opened from remote locations. Connected to the servers multiple users could open the same slide and create a teleconsultation group where synchronized view is possible as well. With these servers students are able to review the slides before or after practices or preparing for examinations [14–16].
We are confident, and have showed as well, that digital slides have got numerous advantages over optical slides and are more suitable in education. One of their most important qualities is the potential for standardisation, as they provide the opportunity to show exactly the same material for each student. Access for any digital material, be it a medical database or a digital slide server is far more easier comparing it to the way how students used to loan text books from libraries or consulting on glass slides. The growing importance of informatics in health care and the expected capability of medical doctors to handle many sources of digital materials raise further questions. Medical training programs must add informatics to their curriculum and training materials need to be developed . In special fields of postgraduate training, such as pathology and radiology it is worth considering to organize short courses on digital imaging and photography .
The program was supported by the János Arányi Foundation, Budapest and 3DHISTECH Ltd., Budapest. All Mirax products were provided by 3DHISTECH Ltd., Budapest. We wish to acknowledge the help of the technician staff of the institute, namely Renáta Kiss who helped in scanning the slides and Attila Tagscherer who supervises the Pathonet server.
- Rocha R, Vassallo J, Soares F, Miller K, Gobbi H: Digital slides: Present status of a tool for consultation, teaching, and quality control in pathology. Pathology Research and Practice. 2009, 205: 735-741. 10.1016/j.prp.2009.05.004.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Gabril MY, Yousef GM: Informatics for practicing anatomical pathologists: marking a new era in pathology practice. Modern Pathology. 2010, 23: 349-358. 10.1038/modpathol.2009.190.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Leong F, Leong ASY: Digital imaging in pathology: theoretical and practical considerations, and applications. Pathology. 2004, 36: 234-241. 10.1080/00313020410001721564.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Weinstein RS, Graham AR, Richter LC, Barker GP, Krupinski EA, Lopez AM, Erps KA, Bhattacharyya AK, Yagi Y, Gilbertson JR: Overview of telepathology, virtual microscopy, and whole slide imaging: prospects for the future. Human Pathology. 2009, 40: 1057-1069. 10.1016/j.humpath.2009.04.006.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Costello SSP, Johnston DJ, Dervan PA, O'Shea DG: Development and evaluation of the virtual pathology slide: A new tool in telepathology. Journal of Medical Internet Research. 2003, 5: 37-50. 10.2196/jmir.5.2.e11.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kayser K, Beyer M, Blum S, Kayser G: Recent developments and present status of telepathology. Analytical Cellular Pathology. 2000, 21: 101-106.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Huisman A, Looijen A, van den Brink SM, van Diest PJ: Creation of a fully digital pathology slide archive by high-volume tissue slide scanning. Human Pathology. 2010, 41: 751-757. 10.1016/j.humpath.2009.08.026.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Barco R: Molecular mechanisms of synovial sarcoma development. Ph.D. 2007, Vanderbilt UniversityGoogle Scholar
- Dee FR, Meyerholz DK: Teaching medical pathology in the twenty-first century: virtual microscopy applications. Journal of Veterinary Medical Education. 2007, 34: 431-436.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Dee FR: Virtual microscopy in pathology education. Human Pathology. 2009, 40: 1112-1121. 10.1016/j.humpath.2009.04.010.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Zito FA, Marzullo F, D'Errico D, Salvatore C, Digirolamo R, Labriola A, Pellecchia A: Quicktime virtual reality technology in light microscopy to support medical education in pathology. Modern Pathology. 2004, 17: 728-731. 10.1038/modpathol.3800113.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Szymas J: Teleeducation and telepathology for open and distance education. Analytical Cellular Pathology. 2000, 21: 183-191.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Harris T, Leaven T, Heidger P, Kreiter C, Duncan J, Dick F: Comparison of a virtual microscope laboratory to a regular microscope laboratory for teaching histology. Anatomical Record. 2001, 265: 10-14. 10.1002/ar.1036.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Lundin M, Lundin J, Helin H, Isola J: A digital atlas of breast histopathology: an application of web based virtual microscopy. Journal of Clinical Pathology. 2004, 57: 1288-1291. 10.1136/jcp.2004.018739.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Kronz JD, Silberman MA, Allsbrook WC, Bastacky SI, Burks RT, Cina SJ, Mills SE, Ross JS, Sakr WA, Tomaszewski JE: Pathology residents' use of a Web-based tutorial to improve Gleason grading of prostate carcinoma on needle biopsies. Human Pathology. 2000, 31: 1044-1050. 10.1053/hupa.2000.16278.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Marchevsky AM, Relan A, Baillie S: Self-instructional "virtual pathology" laboratories using web-based technology enhance medical school teaching of pathology. Human Pathology. 2003, 34: 423-429. 10.1016/S0046-8177(03)00089-3.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Golightly C: LIS Curriculum in Clinical Laboratory Sciences. Lab InfoTech Summit. 2008, [http://www.labinfotech.com/Presentations2008/LIS%20Curriculum%20in%20Clinical%20LIS%20Curriculum%20in%20Clinical%20Laboratory%20Sciences.pdf]Google Scholar
- Saikia B, Gupta K, Saikia UN: The modern histopathologist: in the changing face of time. Diagnostic Pathology. 2008, 3: 25-10.1186/1746-1596-3-25.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (<url>http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0</url>), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.