Skip to main content

Table 1 Diagnostic criteria for columnar cell lesions used in the present study

From: Inter-observer variability between general pathologists and a specialist in breast pathology in the diagnosis of lobular neoplasia, columnar cell lesions, atypical ductal hyperplasia and ductal carcinoma in situ of the breast

 

Columnar cell change

Columnar cell hyperplasia

Columnar cell change with atypia

Columnar cell hyperplasia with atypia

 

Flat epithelial atypia

Topography

Terminal duct-lobular unit with variable dilation

Terminal duct-lobular unit with variable dilation

Terminal duct-lobular unit with variable dilation

Terminal duct-lobular unit with variable dilation

Architecture

1 or 2 cell layers

Cell stratification greater than 2 layers, complex cellular configurations are not present

1 or 2 cell layers

Cellular stratification of more than 2 layers, complex cell configurations are not present

Cytology

Columnar cells with ovoid to elongated nuclei orientated perpendicular to the basal membrane; nucleolus absent or inconspicuous.

Columnar cells with ovoid to elongated nuclei orientated perpendicular to the basal membrane; “hobnail” cells might appear with absent or inconspicuous nuclei.

Cytological atypia present (usually low-grade); the cells resemble tubular carcinoma. Mitoses are uncommon.

Cytological atypia present (usually low-grade); the cells resemble tubular carcinoma. Mitoses are uncommon.

Apical decapitation

Often present, not usually prominent.

Often present, might be exaggerated.

Often present, might be exaggerated.

Often present, might be exaggerated.

Intraluminal secretions

Might be present but are not usually prominent.

Might be present and prominent.

Might be present and prominent.

Might be present and prominent.

Calcifications

Might be present

Usually present, might be psammomatous.

Usually present, might be psammomatous.

Usually present, might be psammomatous.

  1. Adapted from Schnitt and Vincent-Salomon[12], Fraser et al.[13], Tavassoli, & Devilee[11].