- Case Report
- Open Access
Signet ring cell variant of follicular thyroid carcinoma: Report of two cases with focus on morphological, expressional and genetic characteristics
Diagnostic Pathology volume 14, Article number: 127 (2019)
Follicular thyroid carcinoma (FTC) is a neoplasm that presents with a micro-follicular growth pattern and a neutrally stained cytoplasm. Seldom, FTCs display unusual morphological characteristics – but given the rarity of these histological subtypes, little is known regarding the underlying genetics and the coupling to patient outcome.
We present two extremely rare cases of minimally invasive FTC with signet ring cell morphology (SRC-FTC) and describe the cytological, microscopic, immunohistochemical and molecular features for both tumors. Both were male patients, age 71 and 51 respectively. The preoperative cytology for both cases could not pinpoint a clear-cut signet ring cell morphology, but a tendency towards nuclear marginalization was seen. The tumors were 38 mm and 22 mm respectively and displayed evident signet ring cell features in subsets of tumor cells as well as degenerative stromal changes. The tumor cells were positive for TTF1, PAX8 and thyroglobulin, and the proliferation indexes were 4% and 1,9% respectively. Both tumors displayed capsular invasion, but not lymphovascular invasion. The tumors were sequenced for mutations in the TERT promoter and 22 additional cancer-related genes, interestingly; one patient was shown to carry a deleterious intronic variant in PTEN, a tumor suppressor gene coupled to thyroid tumorigenesis and Cowden syndrome. Both patients are alive and well awaiting postoperative radioiodine treatment.
The SRC-FTCs described herein were small, TERT promoter wildtype tumors exhibiting low proliferation, thereby suggesting that these exceedingly rare lesions probably carry a favorable prognosis – although the scarce availability regarding descriptions of this tumor entity nevertheless might justify careful clinical monitoring and mandate investigations in larger case series.
Follicular thyroid tumors constitute the most common thyroid neoplasia, and are categorized as follicular adenomas (FTAs), follicular tumors with uncertain malignant potential (FT-UMPs) and follicular carcinomas (FTCs). The FTCs are furthermore split into three different groups based on histological features: minimally invasive FTCs, encapsulated angio-invasive FTCs and widely invasive FTCs . Regularly, follicular thyroid tumors are seen with a neutrally stained cytoplasm, but subsets of tumors present with an eosinophilic cytoplasm (oncocytic cell tumors). More uncommonly encountered histological variants include follicular tumors with clear-cell or signet ring cell (SRC) morphology, two poorly characterized entities based on the scarce literature available [2,3,4,5,6,7,8].
The SRC appearance in tumors is most intimately coupled to gastric carcinoma, but the phenotype is also reported in adenocarcinomas from other primary sites . The morphological hallmark is defined as a vacuolization of the cytoplasm that marginalizes the nucleus. The causes underlying the SRC morphology include interactions between mucin 4 (MUC4) and ErbB2/Her2, leading to a constitutively active stimulation of cell growth as well as mucin vacuolization [10, 11].
In the thyroid gland, SRC features derive from either accumulations of mucin, lipids, glycogen and thyroglobulin, and have been described for secretory carcinoma, papillary thyroid cancer (PTC), noninvasive follicular thyroid neoplasm with papillary-like nuclear features (NIFTP), FTA and FTC [3,4,5,6, 8]. The description stems from single case reports and small case series with less than 30 reported SRC cases in total - of which FTCs with this phenotype constitute seven cases.
The underlying molecular alterations of these lesions have only been partly dissected. In a previous study of thyroid SRC tumors, single PTEN and FGFR3 mutations were found in an FTA and NIFTP respectively, as well as an ETV6-NTRK3 fusion in a secretory carcinoma of the thyroid .
In this study, two exceedingly rare cases of minimally invasive follicular thyroid carcinomas presenting with SRCs are detailed from cytological, histological and molecular aspects.
The patient is a 71-year old man of Swedish ethnicity without family history of thyroid related diseases. Previous medical conditions include paroxysmal atrial fibrillations, hypertension, a cerebrovascular lesion and malignant melanoma. In 2018, the patient was hospitalized for a minor trauma, and a CT scan of the thorax fortuitously visualized a thyroid lesion, measuring 50 mm. The patient was clinically euthyroid. A cytological fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy was performed, and the diagnosis was consistent with a follicular neoplasm, Bethesda IV, with a low proliferation count of 2% as determined by a cytological Ki-67 index. Following a retrospective evaluation, subsets of cells displayed suggestive nuclear marginalization, but no clear-cut signet ring cell appearance was noted (Fig. 1a). The patient was referred to our department, and ultrasonographic examination of the neck revealed a 42 mm, partly cystic nodule in the caudal aspects of the left thyroid lobe. The patient underwent a diagnostic thyroidal lobectomy in September the same year.
The left thyroid lobe measured 70 × 50 × 30 mm and displayed a weight of 50 g. At gross examination, a demarcated and encapsulated lesion measuring 38 × 30 × 36 mm with a tan cut surface, focal hemorrhages and a central cystic clearing of 25 mm was observed (Fig. 1b). Histological examination revealed a circumscribed lesion consisting of sparsely to densely cellular areas against a background of a fibrous and hemorrhagic stroma. The cells were growing in a predominant micro-follicular pattern, and exhibited enlarged, oval to irregularly shaped nuclei with a finely dispersed chromatin and prominent nucleolus. No nuclear features suggestive of papillary thyroid carcinoma were seen. In the majority of cells, the cytoplasm was observed with a balloon-like vacuolized dilation with an accompanied marginalization of the nucleus, corresponding to signet ring cell morphology (Fig. 1c). No mucinous deposits in the surrounding stroma were seen. Tumor necrosis was not present, and the mitotic count was not elevated. Several areas with capsular invasion were noted, but no focus with vascular invasion was observed (Fig. 1d).
The tumor cells were positive for cytokeratin MNF116, cytokeratin 7, TTF1, PAX8 and thyroglobulin (Fig. 1e-g, Table 1). A subset of the vacuoles stained positive for thyroglobulin but were negative for periodic-acid-schiff (PAS) and PAS-diastase stains (Fig. 1h). MUC5Ac was seen with focal and weak positive staining, but in similar intensities as the surrounding normal thyroid tissues. The tumor cells were negative for cytokeratin 20, CDX2, calcitonin, PTH, MUC2, MUC4, MUC6 and mucicarmine. The Ki-67-index was 4%. Differential diagnoses such as medullary thyroid carcinoma, metastatic signet ring cell carcinoma of the GI tract, parathyroid carcinoma, primary mucinous carcinoma and mammary analog secretory carcinoma were ruled out.
The diagnosis was consistent with a minimally invasive follicular thyroid carcinoma with signet ring cell morphology according to the WHO 2017 classification of endocrine tumors . The tumor was excised with negative margins, and no extrathyroidal extension was seen. The pTNM stage was pT2Nx (Table 1). Cytological re-investigation of the preoperative FNA biopsy material did pinpoint scarce subsets of tumor cells exhibiting a tendency of nuclear marginalization, but noticeably no clear-cut signet ring cell phenotypes.
Using next-generation sequencing (NGS) analysis, no somatic hotspot mutations were found among the 22 genes analyzed, and the tumor was wildtype for both positions C228 and C250 of the TERT promoter. However, two fairly common intronic single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) were detected, one in DDR2 and one in SMAD4, both predicted to be non-deleterious using a panel of in silico prediction software (Table 2). Moreover, using real-time PCR, no ETV6-NTRK3 fusion transcripts were detected (data not shown).
The patient was discussed at a tumor board conference and was planned for a right-sided completion lobectomy and subsequently radioiodine ablation (RAI) with a total dose of 1,1 G-Becquerel (GBq). The right thyroid lobe displayed a physiological C cell hyperplasia, but no tumors.
The second patient is a 51-year old male of Middle-Eastern origin, presenting with diabetes and hypertension. He has no family history of thyroid related disease. In conjunction to CT scan investigations that led to the discovery of an aneurysm of the ascending aorta, the radiologist reported a 20 mm large nodule in the caudal aspect of the right thyroid lobe. An initial FNA biopsy was inconclusive, but re-biopsy was consistent with a follicular lesion of undetermined significance (Bethesda III), with follicular-patterned, cytoplasmic-rich cells with focal intra-cytoplasmic presence of pink, dot-like amorphous deposits. In addition, subsets of cells displayed a tendency of marginalization of the nuclei (Fig. 2a). The patient underwent a right-sided hemithyroidectomy. The excided thyroid lobe displayed a weight of 12 g and measured 42 × 31 × 19 mm. At gross examination, an encapsulated tumor measuring 22 × 19 × 12 mm with a tan to yellowish cut surface was observed. Macroscopically, there were areas in which the tumor engaged the capsule.
The histological examination revealed a circumscribed lesion consisting of tumor cells with a principal micro-follicular growth pattern. The tumor cells were seen with small, relatively monomorphic nuclei with a homogenous chromatin and a punctate nucleolus, and a large subset of tumor cells exhibited a signet ring cell phenotype with a prominent vacuolization of the cytoplasmic compartment with a peripheral marginalization of the tumor nuclei (Fig. 2b). Areas with central degeneration consisting of a fibrous and hypocellular stroma were also observed (Fig. 2c). No nuclear features of papillary thyroid carcinoma were seen. No mitoses or areas with tumor necrosis were observed. Several areas with capsular invasion were noted (Fig. 2d). The tumor was devoid of extrathyroidal extension, and surgical margins were negative.
Immunohistochemical analyses confirmed the tumor as thyroid-derived, as the cells were uniformly positive for cytokeratin MNF116, PAX8 and TTF1 (Fig. 2e, Table 1). The majority of the vacuoles stained positive for thyroglobulin, indicating that the distension of the cytoplasmic compartment at least to some extent stems from inappropriate thyroglobulin accumulation (Fig. 2f). PTEN immunohistochemistry was also positive (Fig. 2g). Negative immunoreactivity was seen for chromogranin A, calcitonin, MUC2, MUC4, MUC5AC, MUC6 and CDX2. The Ki-67 index was 1.9%. The cells were also negative when assessed with a periodic-acid-schiff (PAS) stain.
The final diagnosis was a minimally invasive follicular thyroid carcinoma with signet ring cell morphology, pT2Nx. Other areas of the thyroid lobe exhibited features of Hashimoto’s thyroiditis.
Two variants were detected in somatic DNA: an unusual intronic SNP in ALK (rs745932805) as well as a previously unreported intronic variant in PTEN (Table 2, Fig. 2h). The PTEN variant (chr10: 87925568 T > G, c.209 + 11 T > G) is located in intron 3 of the main PTEN transcript, a region in which similar alterations has been judged as pathogenic and coupled to the skipping of exons 3 and/or 4 in subsets of Cowden syndrome patients . Sanger sequencing analyses of histologically normal thyroid DNA from FFPE material as well as leukocyte DNA from blood preoperatively drawn from the patient confirmed the variant as constitutional. Since the variant is not listed in the SNP repositories (dbSNP, 1000 Genomes, and the Exome Variant Server), we consider this a PTEN intronic mutation. Further analysis with a panel of in silico prediction softwares verified the mutation as deleterious (Table 2). Using Mutation Taster, the mutation was not presumed to abrogate any potential splice sites, but the nucleotide change was predicted to create new transcription factor binding sites for 33 transcription factors (TFs) and disrupt the assumed binding site for 13 additional TFs (Additional file 1: Table S1). Several TFs with an altered binding site display a known coupling to thyroid tumorigenesis, including CREB1, FOXA1, YY1 and RXRA to name a few [13,14,15,16]. As the auxiliary immunohistochemical analysis of the patient’s FTC displayed uniform PTEN immunoreactivity in the tumor cells, this indicates that the overall expressional level of PTEN is retained.
The tumor was wildtype for both positions C228 and C250 of the TERT promoter, as mutations at these sites have been noted as a reliable prognostic indicator of future recurrences in follicular thyroid carcinoma [17, 18]. Moreover, using real-time PCR, no ETV6-NTRK3 fusion transcripts were observed (data not shown).
In the ensuing tumor board conference, the patient was planned for a left-sided completion lobectomy and radioiodine ablation (RAI) with 1,1 G-Becquerel (GBq). The left thyroid lobe displayed features of Hashimoto’s thyroiditis and a cholesterol granuloma, but no tumors.
For both cases, the immunohistochemical stainings were performed in an accredited pathology laboratory using a Ventana Benchmark Ultra system (Ventana Medical Systems, Tucson, AZ, USA). All stainings were assessed by conventional light microscopy by experienced endocrine pathologists (AH and CCJ).
The Oncomine Solid Tumor Panel (Ion Torrent S5, Hi-Q Chef; Thermo Scientific) was used to screen DNA extracted from formalin-fixated paraffin-embedded (FFPE) tissues for > 1800 cancer related mutations within the following genes: EGFR, KRAS, NRAS, PIK3CA, BRAF. ALK, ERBB2, ERBB4, FGFR1, FGFR2, FGFR3, MET, DDR2, AKT1, PTEN, MAP 2 K1, STK11, NOTCH1, CTNNB1, SMAD4, FBXW7 and TP53. The input DNA required was 10 ng.
For TERT, bi-directional Sanger sequencing of the promoter region interrogating the two mutational hotspots C228T and C250T was performed using the Genetic Analyzer 3500, Applied Biosystems, CA, USA  and a conventional protocol in a clinically accredited setting.
For the ETV6-NTRK3 fusion analyses, RNA was extracted from the FFPE material using the Maxwell®16 MX3031 instrument with Maxwell®16 FFPE LEV RNA Purification Kit from Promega (Fitchburg, WI, USA). The quality and quantity of the RNA was estimated through Nanodrop technology (Nanodrop technologies, Wilmington, DE, USA). cDNA was subsequently synthesized using the High-Capacity cDNA reverse transcription Kit (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA, USA). Real-time PCR (TaqMan) was performed in duplicate (ABI, SDS 7000 Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA, USA) targeting the ETV6-NTRK3 fusion transcript corresponding to the chromosomal translocation t (12;15)(p13;q25).
Single nucleotide variants/polymorphisms for all cases were evaluated through the Predict SNP2 platform, in which the variant is classified as either “neutral”, “deleterious” or “unknown” using six different integrated prediction tools: Predict SNP2, Combined Annotation Dependent Depletion (CADD), Deleterious Annotation of Genetic Variants using Neural Networks (DANN), Functional Analysis through Hidden Markov Models (FATHMM), FunSeq2 and Genome-Wide Annotation of Variants (GWAVA) . Extended analyzes for the PTEN variant were performed using the Mutation Taster function .
Discussion and conclusions
Rare morphological variants of thyroid cancer are important to characterize from both a clinical and molecular perspective, so that an eventual coupling to underlying genetics and patient prognosis can be made. This is exemplified by the association between specific histological subtypes in papillary thyroid carcinoma and prognostic features . Although the current WHO classification of endocrine tumors recognizes the SRC subtype of FTC, no information regarding the underlying genetic events and prognosis is presented – making it hard for clinicians to recognize if the SCR-FTC diagnosis should imply specific considerations in the clinical management of the individual patient.
SRC-FTC is an extremely rare entity – and drawing conclusions based on the scarce amount of cases presented in the scientific literature is challenging. Even so, a few similarities between our two cases and previously published thyroid tumors with SRC features were observed. Firstly, it seems as not all preoperative FNA biopsies are able to pinpoint the SRC morphology, including our two cases [5, 6]. Instead, the pinpointing of the SRC features was only evident after histopathological examination. This is possibly due to the fact that the SRC morphology was only observed in approximately half of the tumor cell population (Table 1), which mirrors previous findings in which SRC cells only lined parts of the follicles . Indeed, only after reinvestigation of the cytology specimen, a tendency of marginalization of the nuclei was seen for a subset of tumor cells. Moreover, the cell-sparse, degenerative stromal features seen in both cases might also complicate the analysis. On histological investigation, the distended cytoplasm was positive for thyroglobulin for both cases, indicating aberrant accumulation of this protein as part of the underlying cause of the signet ring phenotype. Secondly, both our cases displayed stromal degeneration, with central areas of the tumor presenting with a dense fibrosis, sparsely populated by stromal cells and few tumor cells. Findings of a desmoplastic tumoral stroma have been previously reported in SRC tumors of the thyroid, indicating this phenomenon as a general part of the tumoral phenotype .
We found a previously unreported, germline mutation in the intron 3 of the tumor suppressor gene PTEN in case 2. Mutations in this intronic region has previously been coupled to Cowden syndrome, as a result of aberrant splicing and exon skipping . Our variant is not thought to disrupt a splice site, but still predicted to be deleterious by in silico analyses. The retained tumoral PTEN immunoreactivity partly argues against an inactivating genetic event, but since the mutation was intronic, the true pathogenicity of this mutation could remain unnoticed by immunohistochemistry. The patient has no previous family history indicative of Cowden syndrome-related tumors, suggesting that the variant might not cause this disease phenotype, alternatively occurring de novo or with a reduced penetrance. DNA from additional family members was not available. Interestingly, an FTA with SRC features harboring a deleterious PTEN missense mutation has previously been reported in a case series of four SRC-FTAs . Therefore, it seems likely that PTEN mutations could constitute a molecular aberrancy underlying the development of subsets of SRC thyroid tumors.
Regarding prognostication of SRC-FTC, little is known. A previous case of SRC-FTC with capsular and angio-invasive properties displayed a 12-month disease-free survival . In our study, both SCR-FTCs displayed capsular invasion, but no areas with lymphovascular invasion were observed – representing a minimally invasive subtype. Moreover, the Ki-67 proliferation indexes were fairly low and no TERT promoter mutations were detected. In all, these factors might indicate a low risk of future recurrences – but careful monitoring is nevertheless justified given the lack of scientific literature covering this very infrequent histological subtype.
We conclude that SRC-FTCs are exceedingly rare, with subsets of cases displaying mutations in genes involved in thyroid tumorigenesis. The tumors may elude correct characterization on preoperative cytological examination based on the tumoral blend of SCR cells and conventional tumor cells. Although based on few cases, the prognosis is believed to be favorable, or at least on par with conventional FTCs.
Availability of data and materials
All data generated or analyzed during this study are included in this published article and its supplementary information files.
Combined Annotation Dependent Depletion
Deleterious Annotation of Genetic Variants using Neural Networks
Functional Analysis through Hidden Markov Models
Fine needle aspiration
Follicular thyroid adenoma
Follicular thyroid carcinoma
Genome-Wide Annotation of Variants
Noninvasive follicular thyroid neoplasm with papillary-like nuclear features
Papillary thyroid cancer
Single nucleotide polymorphisms
FTC with signet ring cell morphology
Weltgesundheitsorganisation, Lloyd RV, Osamura RY, Klöppel G, Rosai J, International Agency for Research on Cancer, editors. WHO classification of tumours of endocrine organs. 4th edition. Lyon: International Agency for Research on Cancer; 2017. 355 p. (World Health Organization classification of tumours).
Carcangiu ML, Sibley RK, Rosai J. Clear cell change in primary thyroid tumors. A study of 38 cases. Am J Surg Pathol. 1985 Oct;9(10):705–22.
Handra-Luca A. Signet-ring cell adenoma of the thyroid and rheumatoid arthritis: incidental association or methotrexate-related change? Reumatologia. 2017;55(4):155–6.
Schröder S, Böcker W. Signet-ring-cell thyroid tumors. Follicle cell tumors with arrest of folliculogenesis. Am J Surg Pathol. 1985 Sep;9(9):619–29.
Romero-Rojas AE, Diaz-Perez JA, Mastrodimos M, Chinchilla SI. Follicular thyroid carcinoma with signet ring cell morphology: fine-needle aspiration cytology, histopathology, and immunohistochemistry. Endocr Pathol. 2013;24(4):239–45.
Farhat NA, Onenerk AM, Krane JF, Dias-Santagata D, Sadow PM, Faquin WC. Primary benign and malignant thyroid neoplasms with signet ring cells: Cytologic, histologic, and molecular features. Am J Clin Pathol. 2017;148(3):251–8.
Juhlin CC, Bränström R, Shabo I, Höög A. Clear cell variant of a follicular thyroid tumor with uncertain malignant potential: a case report. Int J Surg Pathol. 2018 Oct;29:1066896918809490.
Chiofalo MG, Losito NS, Fulciniti F, Setola SV, Tommaselli A, Marone U, et al. Axillary node metastasis from differentiated thyroid carcinoma with Hürthle and signet ring cell differentiation. A case of disseminated thyroid cancer with peculiar histologic findings. BMC Cancer. 2012;12:55.
Pernot S, Voron T, Perkins G, Lagorce-Pages C, Berger A, Taieb J. Signet-ring cell carcinoma of the stomach: impact on prognosis and specific therapeutic challenge. World J Gastroenterol. 2015;21(40):11428–38.
Yokoyama A, Shi B-H, Kawai T, Konishi H, Andoh R, Tachikawa H, et al. Muc4 is required for activation of ErbB2 in signet ring carcinoma cell lines. Biochem Biophys Res Commun. 2007;355(1):200–3.
Fukui Y. Mechanisms behind signet ring cell carcinoma formation. Biochem Biophys Res Commun. 2014;450(4):1231–3.
Chen HJ, Romigh T, Sesock K, Eng C. Characterization of cryptic splicing in germline PTEN intronic variants in Cowden syndrome. Hum Mutat. 2017;38(10):1372–7.
Leone V, Langella C, Esposito F, Arra C, Palma G, Rea D, et al. Ccdc6 knock-in mice develop thyroid hyperplasia associated to an enhanced CREB1 activity. Oncotarget. 2015 20;6(17):15628–38.
Chen X, Li M, Zhou H, Zhang L. miR-132 targets FOXA1 and exerts tumor-suppressing functions in thyroid cancer. Oncol Res. 2018;
Fang M, Huang W, Wu X, Gao Y, Ou J, Zhang X, et al. MiR-141-3p suppresses tumor growth and metastasis in papillary thyroid Cancer via targeting yin Yang 1. Anat Rec (Hoboken). 2018.
Gauchotte G, Lacomme S, Brochin L, Tournier B, Cahn V, Monhoven N, et al. Retinoid acid receptor expression is helpful to distinguish between adenoma and well-differentiated carcinoma in the thyroid. Virchows Arch. 2013 Jun;462(6):619–32.
Hysek M, Paulsson JO, Wang N, Jatta K, Lindh C, Fuentes-Martinez N, et al. TERT promoter mutational screening as a tool to predict malignant behaviour in follicular thyroid tumours-three examples from the clinical routine. Virchows Arch. 2018 Nov;473(5):639–43.
Paulsson JO, Mu N, Shabo I, Wang N, Zedenius J, Larsson C, et al. TERT aberrancies: a screening tool for malignancy in follicular thyroid tumours. Endocr Relat Cancer. 2018;25(7):723–33.
Bendl J, Musil M, Štourač J, Zendulka J, Damborský J, Brezovský J. PredictSNP2: a unified platform for accurately evaluating SNP effects by exploiting the different characteristics of variants in distinct genomic regions. PLoS Comput Biol. 2016;12(5):e1004962.
Schwarz JM, Cooper DN, Schuelke M, Seelow D. MutationTaster2: mutation prediction for the deep-sequencing age. Nat Methods. 2014 Apr;11(4):361–2.
The authors are indebted to Ms. Lisa Ånfalk for her excellent technical assistance.
The study was financially supported by grants generously provided by the Swedish Cancer Society and the Swedish Society for Medical Research.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Ethical approval has been acquired by the local ethical committee, and informed consent has been obtained from the individual patients.
Consent for publication
Both patients have given consent for publication.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Hysek, M., Jatta, K., Stenman, A. et al. Signet ring cell variant of follicular thyroid carcinoma: Report of two cases with focus on morphological, expressional and genetic characteristics. Diagn Pathol 14, 127 (2019) doi:10.1186/s13000-019-0904-3
- Signet ring cell
- Follicular thyroid cancer